As each hour arrived, Andy and Anderson closed their eyes while shooting the mystery liquid as the audience toasted with them. The hosts wore bejeweled Ramona Singer-inspired glasses while the audience learned the non-alcoholic contents of the shot glasses.
The mystery shots included pickle juice, apple cider vinegar, and buttermilk.
Audiences epiphanies included:
- Andy can’t tell the difference between pickle juice and tomato juice
- Anderson claimed he has never eaten a pickle in his life. (Myself, on the other hand…)
Both hosts, who have children thanks to surrogates, chased their mystery shots with juice boxes.
The Watch What Happens Live host stated for the record, “I prefer tequila.”