• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Taste of Reality

Taste of Reality

Reality TV News & Discussion

  • Latest Buzz
  • Live Discussions
  • Shows
    • Bachelor Nation
    • Below Deck
    • Dancing With the Stars
    • Love Is Blind
    • Real Housewives
    • Next Gen NYC
    • Secret Lives of Mormon Wives
    • Southern Charm
    • Southern Hospitality
    • Summer House
    • The Valley
    • Traitors
    • Vanderpump Rules
  • Taste Test
  • Watch
  • About
  • Shop
  • Search
Buzz

Scheana Shay Called Out Jesse Lally’s Messy Girlfriend And A Fan Theory About The “Baywatch Guy”

Apr 29, 2025 By Ashley B What do you think?

FacebookTweetEmail
Scheana Shay Jesse Lally Lacy Nicole

Scheana Shay weighed in on The Valley‘s Jesse Lally and the conversation fans heard about his ‘girlfriend,’ Lacy Nicole, not being on the same page as him relationship-wise.

It all happened … according to Scheana:

Allegedly, Lacy bragged to Scheana about how she was “sleeping with a dude from Baywatch” while they both attended a kid’s birthday party.

“There’s an open bar,” began Scheana. Lacy “has a few too many and is being very open with me. Jesse’s kind of within earshot. I was like, ‘Why are you telling this to me?’ Like someone in the friend group who is friends, very closely, with his ex-wife, [Michelle Saniei].”

“I’m enjoying the open bar [and] I’m texting Brock and Michelle.” I was like, ‘I can’t believe [Jesse’s girlfriend is] saying this to me.'”

“Other people heard it. It wasn’t a one-on-one conversation. I thought that was really weird. She’s like, ‘He’s not my boyfriend.’ She said this to multiple people. So, the fact that they’re still together, I think, I don’t know.”

“I genuinely felt bad. [Jesse] finding out that information for the first time [on camera]. I even apologized.”

Ok, but who is the guy from Baywatch?

Scheana didn’t reveal who the “guy from Baywatch” was. But, fans suspect the rumor is about David Charvet. This theory has yet to be confirmed.

David starred as Matt Brody on the Baywatch TV series from Seasons 3 to 6, based on the information that both Lacy and David follow each other on Instagram. You may remember David from his stint on Melrose Place, his massive music career overseas, or being married to Brooke Burke.

According to Stylecaster, “Lacy follows other male Baywatch stars—including David Hasselhof and Kelly Slater, Charvet is the only one who follows her back.”

Drop your thoughts about Scheana’s admission about Jesse’s girlfriend(?), Lacy, and the fan theory on ‘the Baywatch guy’ below.

FacebookTweetEmail

Bravo TV The Valley Bravo Bravo TV Buzz Jesse Lally Lacy Nicole Scheana shay The Valley Vanderpump Rules VPR

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

rhony live discussion season 16

The Real Housewives Of New York – Live Discussion ‘Much Ado About Brunching’ Season 16, Episode 2

What do you think?

Sarah Jane Hailey

Sarah Jane Nader Embraces LGBTQ+ Representation With DWTS Season 35 Debut

What do you think?

Alexia Todd Nepola back together rhom

Alexia Nepola Says She and Todd Nepola Are Back Together: “Love Wins”

What do you think?

Steven McBee Sr. released prison

Steve McBee Sr. Returns Home After Early Prison Release

What do you think?

Ciara Miller Whitney Houston

Ciara Miller’s Emmys Dress Has a Special Connection to Her DWTS Debut

What do you think?

Layla Taylor slomw fate mikayla matthews

Layla Taylor Gives Season 6 Filming Update Following Mikayla Matthews’ Mormon Wives Exit

What do you think?

Trending Now 🔥

  • KJ SA family memberKJ Biermann Faces New Sexual Allegation Involving Underage Family Member – CONTENT WARNING0 Comments
  • Sandoval The ValleyTom Sandoval Addresses Joining The Valley After Cast Exits0 Comments
  • Brandi Glanville GoFundMeBrandi Glanville’s Friend Launches GoFundMe Amid Ongoing Health Struggles0 Comments
  • Kroy Biermann gambling debtKroy Biermann Ordered to Pay More Than $64K Over Gambling Debt0 Comments
  • Brielle moving forward with weddingBrielle Biermann Is Moving Forward With Her November Wedding Amid Brother KJ’s Arrest0 Comments
  • Scheana Shay VPR regret one more time music videoScheana Shay Reveals Her Biggest Vanderpump Rules Regret and How She Scrubbed It From the Internet0 Comments

We are serving up the perfect taste of pop culture. Get the latest reality TV news and sound off in our active discussions!

Tell us what you really think.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • X
  • TikTok
  • YouTube
  • Mail

Top Categories

  • 90 Day Fiancé
  • Bachelor Nation
  • Bravo TV
  • Dancing With the Stars
  • E!
  • Hulu
  • Kardashian Jenner Family
  • Love Is Blind
  • Netflix
  • Real Housewives
  • Southern Charm
  • Summer House
  • TLC
  • Vanderpump Rules

Disclaimers

This site is not affiliated with or endorsed by any shows or networks. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

© 2026 · Taste of Reality · Terms of Use · Privacy Policy · Contact Us