Erin Foster was visibly stunned when she was asked about her alleged relationship with Harry Styles a decade ago.
A super-sleuth Swiftie was a virtual guest on Watch What Happens Live. She asked the creator of Netflix‘s Nobody Wants This a question this Swiftie wasn’t ready for. (And neither was David Foster’s daughter!)
The savage Swiftie managed to get an answer for a question I had from the Taylor Swift song Is It Over Now? from 1989 (Taylor’s Version) that I was NOT prepared to get answered on WWHL.
The Q&A:
The virtual caller asked, “Can you now confirm or deny the dating rumors of you and Harry Styles in 2014?”
Eager for the hot goss, Christian Siriano (who was the other WWHL guest) demanded Erin Foster, “Confirm it. Just say it.” Katharine McPhee’s stepdaughter plead the fifth. “I can’t confirm or deny anything. Guys. Are you allowed to plead the fifth on this show? Ok, good. I’m using my rights.”
While Andy Cohen and Christian agreed they would scream from the rooftops that they dated Harry Styles, Erin – like Taylor Swift – decided to Shake It Off (Taylor’s Version).
According to the Project Runway winner turned host (and myself), Erin pleading the fifth low-key confirmed she dated the One Direction member. But that’s just our opinions.
Christian, Bravo TV‘s Father of Fashion, joked that Erin could base her next hit show around dating THE Harry Styles!
Will Erin Foster finally confirm or deny the dating rumors about her and Harry Styles from 2014? pic.twitter.com/93NAm8ZrNK
— Watch What Happens Live! (@BravoWWHL) October 1, 2024
But, why do Swifties (me, I am Swifties) care?
Taylor’s fifth album, 1989, was released in October of 2014. When 1989 (Taylor’s Version) was released in October of 2023, several songs dropped that were ‘locked in lower case inside a vault‘ (that’s T.S. for ‘unreleased’).
One of the previously unreleased songs, Is It Over Now?, is CLEARLY about her relationship about Harry Styles. (I could write a dissertation on this, but I’ll spare you.)
Here are the telling lyrics from Is It Over Now?
“When you lost control (uh-huh)Red blood, white snow (uh-huh)”
The above two lines refer to the snowmobile accident Harry and Taylor were in together when they dated (reference her song ‘Out of the Woods’ for more info on this.)
“Blue dress on a boat (uh-huh)”
The third line of this verse references paparazzi photos of Taylor (donned in a blue dress) and Harry on a boat together.
Timeline👏:
Harry and Taylor’s snowmobile accident was days before Christmas in 2012.
They broke up in January 2013.
1989 was released on October 27, 2014.
Erin Foster ‘plead the fifth’ to dating Harry in 2014 (which is basically confirmation for shady AF Bravo fans…)
