• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Taste of Reality

Taste of Reality

Reality TV News & Discussion

  • Latest Buzz
  • Live Discussions
  • Shows
    • Bachelor Nation
    • Below Deck
    • Dancing With the Stars
    • Love Is Blind
    • Real Housewives
    • Next Gen NYC
    • Secret Lives of Mormon Wives
    • Southern Charm
    • Southern Hospitality
    • Summer House
    • The Valley
    • Traitors
    • Vanderpump Rules
  • Taste Test
  • Watch
  • About
  • Shop
  • Search
Buzz

Natalie Maguire And Marcus Johnson Discuss OG Cast Comparisons – Who Is The Scheana Shay?

Dec 10, 2025 By Ashley B What do you think?

FacebookTweetEmail
Scheana Marcus Natalie

SURvers Natalie Maguire and Marcus Johnson were guests on the Mention It All podcast to discuss their new reality as reality TV stars.

A struggle they’ve already faced lies in comparison to the OG cast.

Comparison is the thief of joy:

Natalie began with her version of the adage: “The thing that’s driven me crazy is when people are like, ‘They’re trying so hard.'” She refuted, “I’m like, ‘We ain’t trying.'”

Marcus agreed. “You haven’t even seen us yet. What do you mean we’re trying too hard?!”

The host, Dylan Hafer, mentioned that VPR fans are trying to find who correlate the new cast with the OGs, like Scheana Shay.

Marcus was quick to clap back to the haters. “No really YOU want to be Scheana. You’re just mad because I’m here right now, b*tch. You ain’t.”

“It’s hard to get up there and do it,” concluded Natalie.

Former VPR star Lala Kent entered the chat:

Last month, SUR’s former hostess encouraged the VanderVerse to extend kindness to the rebooted cast. “You guys. I heard [season 12 of VPR is] really good. I hope everyone gives [the new VPR] a chance.”

“Here’s the thing,” continued Lala. “I’m sure the cast is very excited, but also freaking out. I’m sure they’re getting a lot of hate right now.”

“So please congratulate these people. They’re young, wild, and free in LA. They’re just having a good time and got asked to be on a TV show. Freaking awesome. Be happy for them.”

“It’s not going to be how it was with us. It’s going to be new and different. So just take it for what it is. Sit back and enjoy,” added Lala.

Let us know what you think about Scheana catching a stray from Marcus and Natalie below.

FacebookTweetEmail

Bravo TV Vanderpump Rules Bravo Buzz Marcus Johnson Natalie Maguire Vanderpump Rules VPR

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

Kyle Richards smoking claims rhugt

Kyle Richards Denies Being “California Sober” Following RHUGT Vape Scene

What do you think?

Next Gen NYC season 2

Next Gen NYC: Live Discussion ‘Reunion Part 1’ Season 2, Episode 13

What do you think?

RHOSLC 7 Live Discussion

Real Housewives of Salt Lake City: Season 7, Episode 1

What do you think?

DWTS 35 Live Discussion

Dancing with the Stars: Live Discussion ‘Girls Night’ Season 35, Episode 2

What do you think?

Chris Harrison The Vow

Chris Harrison Is Back! Meet the 30-Year-Old Bachelor Leading ‘The Vow’

What do you think?

American Idol relocation

American Idol Is Leaving Los Angeles for Georgia

What do you think?

Trending Now 🔥

  • KJ SA family memberKJ Biermann Faces New Sexual Allegation Involving Underage Family Member – CONTENT WARNING0 Comments
  • Sandoval The ValleyTom Sandoval Addresses Joining The Valley After Cast Exits0 Comments
  • Brandi Glanville GoFundMeBrandi Glanville’s Friend Launches GoFundMe Amid Ongoing Health Struggles0 Comments
  • Kroy Biermann gambling debtKroy Biermann Ordered to Pay More Than $64K Over Gambling Debt0 Comments
  • Brielle moving forward with weddingBrielle Biermann Is Moving Forward With Her November Wedding Amid Brother KJ’s Arrest0 Comments
  • DWTS elimination and themeDWTS Season 35 Premiere Week Twist Revealed & Week One Theme Spoilers0 Comments

We are serving up the perfect taste of pop culture. Get the latest reality TV news and sound off in our active discussions!

Tell us what you really think.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • X
  • TikTok
  • YouTube
  • Mail

Top Categories

  • 90 Day Fiancé
  • Bachelor Nation
  • Bravo TV
  • Dancing With the Stars
  • E!
  • Hulu
  • Kardashian Jenner Family
  • Love Is Blind
  • Netflix
  • Real Housewives
  • Southern Charm
  • Summer House
  • TLC
  • Vanderpump Rules

Disclaimers

This site is not affiliated with or endorsed by any shows or networks. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

© 2026 · Taste of Reality · Terms of Use · Privacy Policy · Contact Us