Monica Garcia might not be a one-season wonder just yet!
The former Real Housewives of Salt Lake City star opened up on the Viall Files podcast about a fan theory that’s been floating around for a while — that she and Jen Shah could make their return in the same season.
As of now, Jen is set to be released from prison on November 3, 2026. But with time being chipped off her sentence every few months, fans are already speculating about a Bravo comeback.
Since Monica was once Jen’s close friend — before spending her single season airing out Jen’s dirty laundry — it would make sense for producers to consider a dramatic joint return.
“Everyone seems to think that the big master plan is for them to bring me and Jen back at the same time,” Monica shared on the podcast.
But Monica had one clear condition:
“It can’t be all of them against me again. I can’t go through that again. If they can at least give me one person, I’d be fine.”
While Whitney Rose seems the likeliest ally, her loyalty to Heather Gay — one of Monica’s harshest critics — could complicate that.
Of course, the fandom is divided. Half of viewers don’t want Bravo rewarding Jen’s criminal past with airtime.
Still, others (myself included!) feel a return could bring closure. The same way Teresa Giudice’s post-prison comeback gave RHONJ one of its strongest eras.
We never got real resolution with Jen’s downfall, and Monica’s abrupt exit left unfinished business.
Like it or not, their returns could bring mess and ratings.
Listen Below:
