Below Deck alum João Franco and his brother, Karlos Franco, could spend the rest of their lives behind bars following a deadly altercation in Bodrum, Turkey.
The siblings were recently arrested after a fistfight on November 7 allegedly resulted in the death of a 17-year-old boy. Now, a criminal defense attorney familiar with Turkey’s legal system is explaining the potential consequences they could face.
Todd Spodek, a New York federal criminal defense attorney, told Page Six that the brothers’ fate will largely depend on whether the Bodrum Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office decides to indict them and what charges prosecutors ultimately pursue.
The possible charges range from negligent homicide to intentional killing. The latter carries a potential life sentence, while intentional injury resulting in death can result in 10 to 18 years behind bars, depending on whether aggravated circumstances apply. Negligent homicide carries a prison sentence of two to six years.
“The single most important question in this case is how Turkish prosecutors charge it because that decides almost everything about the sentence,” Spodek explained.
“If they treat it as an intentional killing, the brothers are facing a potential life sentence. If it’s charged the way these bar-fight cases often are, as an assault that unintentionally resulted in death, the exposure drops to roughly a decade or more.” The attorney continued, “If a court finds it was reckless rather than intentional, it drops further still.”
The attorney also pointed to a possible middle ground known as “eventual intent.” This applies when someone did not intend to kill another person but knew their actions could result in death.
However, Spodek admitted he would be “surprised if prosecutors could prove intentional killing from one punch and a fall.”





