• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Taste of Reality

Taste of Reality

Reality TV News & Discussion

  • Latest Buzz
  • Live Discussions
  • Shows
    • Bachelor Nation
    • Below Deck
    • Dancing With the Stars
    • Love Is Blind
    • Real Housewives
    • Next Gen NYC
    • Secret Lives of Mormon Wives
    • Southern Charm
    • Southern Hospitality
    • Summer House
    • The Valley
    • Traitors
    • Vanderpump Rules
  • Taste Test
  • Watch
  • About
  • Shop
  • Search
Buzz

Jesse Metcalfe Confirmed He Dated Scheana Shay

Jul 17, 2025 By Ashley B What do you think?

FacebookTweetEmail
jesse metcalfe dated scheana

Jesse Metcalfe discussed dating Scheana Shay during an episode of the misSPELLING podcast.

The actor best known for playing John the hot gardener on Desperate Housewives as well as the title role in John Tucker Must Die dated the Vanderpump Rules OG two decades ago.

The podcast host, Tori Spelling, mentioned that Scheana name-dropped him in her memoir, My Good Side.

Jesse Metcalf seemingly only has a good side:

“There’s no dirt on you,” joked the Beverly Hills 90210 actress on prepping for the interview. “Except Scheana, but that was…”

Jesse jumped in, “I know. She spoke highly of me, which was nice.” He added, “You’re breaking that news to my girlfriend live, by the way.”

He added that he dated Scheana a “long time ago, 20 years ago.”

Tori wanted clarification. “She said she was dating you. Do you feel like you were dating her?”

“We were dating. Overall, it was pretty brief, but we were seeing each other on a regular basis.”

Tori asked about Jesse and Scheana’s origin story. “We met through a mutual friend who happened to be her boss,” explained Jesse.

“So, her boss and I went to the same gym. He had mentioned that she thought I was handsome, and we ended up going out.”

ICYMI:

Scheana revealed that she had a brief romance with Metcalfe in early 2007, between her hookups with Eddie Cibrian. 

The Good As Gold crooner described it as a fun, fantasy-like experience, including dates and even him serenading her with songs.

Drop your thoughts about Jesse and Scheana dating in the comments.

FacebookTweetEmail

Bravo TV Pop Culture News The Valley Vanderpump Rules Bravo Buzz Desperate Housewives Jesse Metcalfe John Tucker Must Die Scheana shay VPR

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

Dakota Mortensen suing Hulu defamation

Taylor Frankie Paul’s Ex Dakota Mortensen Sues Hulu for Defamation Over ‘Secret Lives of Mormon Wives’ Portrayal

What do you think?

Taylor Frankie Paul Sam Hartman

Taylor Frankie Paul Shoots Her Shot With ABC’s Newest Bachelor, Sam Hartman

What do you think?

Jen Shah Elizabeth Holmes doc

Jen Shah Reportedly Attending Private Screening of Elizabeth Holmes Documentary

What do you think?

KJ block forensic interviews

KJ Biermann Appeals Judge’s Ruling Allowing Prosecutors to Interview Minor Children & Conduct Forensic Interviews in Sexual Battery Case

What do you think?

LALU Relationship Rehab Live Discussion

Love After Lockup: Relationship Rehab – Live Discussion ‘Sink or Swim?’ Episode 7

What do you think?

Justin Johnson estate suing prison

Justin Johnson’s Estate Sues Prison Officials Over His Death

What do you think?

Trending Now 🔥

  • Aaryn blames racism on father‘Small Town Trouble: Texas’ Star Aaryn Williams Says Father Instilled Racist Beliefs Before ‘Big Brother’ Scandal0 Comments
  • Scheana Shay House of Stassi filming rumorIs Scheana Shay Joining Season 2 of House of Stassi?0 Comments
  • Zac Jen Affleck DWTS nightmareZac Affleck Was Reportedly a ‘Nightmare’ During Jen Affleck’s Time On DWTS0 Comments
  • Leah Remini fire RHOBH castLeah Remini Says She’d Recast RHOBH Every Three Years – Agrees With Fan Criticisms Of The Show’s “Bully” Culture0 Comments
  • Emily Simpson luke diagnosis Tourette’sEmily Simpson Opens Up About Son Luke’s Tourette’s Diagnosis During RHOC Reunion0 Comments
  • Kim Kroy KJ siblingsKim Zolciak and Kroy Biermann’s Younger Children File Appeal in KJ’s Sexual Battery Case0 Comments

We are serving up the perfect taste of pop culture. Get the latest reality TV news and sound off in our active discussions!

Tell us what you really think.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • X
  • TikTok
  • YouTube
  • Mail

Top Categories

  • 90 Day Fiancé
  • Bachelor Nation
  • Bravo TV
  • Dancing With the Stars
  • E!
  • Hulu
  • Kardashian Jenner Family
  • Love Is Blind
  • Netflix
  • Real Housewives
  • Southern Charm
  • Summer House
  • TLC
  • Vanderpump Rules

Disclaimers

This site is not affiliated with or endorsed by any shows or networks. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

© 2026 · Taste of Reality · Terms of Use · Privacy Policy · Contact Us